The Wild Photographer
The Wild Photographer is a podcast for wildlife, nature, landscape, and travel photographers who want to make better photos and get more out of photography.
Hosted by professional photographer, biologist, expedition leader, and photo guide Court Whelan, PhD, the show combines practical photography advice with lessons learned from photographing wildlife and wild places around the world.
Episodes cover wildlife photography techniques, camera settings, lenses and gear, composition, landscape and travel photography, editing, creativity, and fieldcraft, along with conversations with professional photographers and visual storytellers.
Whether you're a beginner or an experienced photographer, expect approachable advice you can actually use in the field, plus plenty of adventure, curiosity, and enthusiasm for the craft.
The Wild Photographer
Love 'em or Hate 'em? Five Pieces of Controversial Photography Gear Explained
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Can using a tripod actually make you a worse photographer? Are $15,000 super-telephoto lenses really worth it? And could a crop-sensor camera actually be better than full-frame for wildlife photography?
Photographers have surprisingly strong opinions about gear. But after years of guiding photography expeditions around the world, I've come to realize that some of the most passionately debated pieces of equipment don't have a clear right or wrong answer.
In this episode of The Wild Photographer, I'm diving into five surprisingly "controversial" pieces of camera gear, exploring why some photographers swear by them while others avoid them entirely. From giant wildlife lenses and teleconverters to tripods, crop sensors, and polarizing filters, I'll break down the advantages, disadvantages, and my own field-tested opinions.
The goal isn't to convince you to buy more gear—or throw anything out. It's to help you think more critically about the equipment you already have and make better decisions for the photography you actually do.
What You'll Learn in This Episode
- Tripods: Essential or creativity killers? Why tripods are indispensable for long exposures, astrophotography, and certain landscapes, but can also slow you down and discourage experimentation with composition.
- Giant super-telephoto primes vs. zoom lenses: The extraordinary image quality and low-light advantages of 400mm f/2.8 and 600mm f/4 lenses versus the versatility, portability, and freedom of telephoto zooms.
- Crop sensors vs. full-frame for wildlife: Understanding crop factors, pixel density, the myth of "extra reach," and when a smaller sensor might actually put more useful pixels on your subject.
- Teleconverters: Brilliant innovation or optical compromise? Why I'm much more enthusiastic about 1.4x teleconverters than 2x versions, and when cropping your image might be the better solution.
- Circular polarizers: Amazing tools that are often overused: How polarizers can eliminate reflections and improve landscapes in ways editing software can't easily replicate—and why permanently leaving one on your lens might be a mistake.
- Bonus: The great UV-filter debate. Why I use high-quality protective filters on most of my lenses, despite understanding why other photographers won't touch them.
Links & Resources Mentioned
Related Podcast Episodes and Photographers
- Talking with Will Patino: The 4 Pillars of Landscape Photography, Simple Editing Techniques, and Why He Ditched the Tripod — My conversation with landscape photographer Will Patino, including his remarkable handheld landscape photography techniques.
- Will Patino Photography — Will's landscape photography, workshops, and educational resources.
- UV Filters Explained: Worth It, Overrated, or Essential Lens Protection? — My full deep dive into the pros, cons, and considerations of using protective filters.
- All About Camera Sensors: Understand Them and Improve Your Photography — A deeper explanation of sensor size, pixels, ISO, and image quality.
- Landscape Photography 101 & 102: Tips to Instantly Elevate Your Landscape Photos — More about tripod use, composition, and camera settings for landscapes.
Lenses and Teleconverters Discussed
These are examples of the types of equipment discussed in the episode, rather than a definitive shopping list.
- Canon RF 400mm f/2.8 L IS USM
- Canon RF 600mm f/4 L IS USM
- Canon RF 100–500mm f/4.5–7.1 L IS USM
- Tamron SP 150–600mm f/5–6.3 G2
- Canon RF 1.4x Teleconverter
- Canon RF 2x Teleconverter
Polarizing and Protective Filters
A few of the filter manufacturers and options I discuss:
- PolarPro QuartzLine Filters — Circular polarizers and UV filters.
- Hoya HD3 UV Filters — Premium multi-coated protective filters.
- B+W UV and Clear Protection Filters — Including the MASTER series.
- Singh-Ray Filters — Premium specialty filters.
Keep Learning Photography
For more photography tutorials, editing demonstrations, gear discussions, and lessons from the field, check out my YouTube channel, Court Whelan.
And I'd love to hear your thoughts on this episode! What's a piece of photography gear you absolutely love that everyone else seems to hate? Or something you think is completely overrated?
Head over to my YouTube channel and leave a comment. Your answer might just inspire a Part Two!
Remember: The best piece of camera gear isn't necessarily the most expensive, the sharpest, or the one other photographers tell you to buy. It's the one that helps you make the photograph you actually want to make.
Court's Websites
- Check out my photo portfolio here: shop.courtwhelan.com
- Sign up for my photo and conservation blog at www.courtwhelan.com
- Follow me on YouTube (@courtwhelan) for more photography tips
- View my camera kit and recommended camera gear
Sponsors and Promo Codes:
- MPB.com - Buy, Sell, or Trade Camera Gear
- ArtStorefronts.com - Mention this podcast for free photo website design
- BayPhoto.com - 25% off your first order (code: TWP25)
- ArtHelper.com - a photo community to learn, share and be inspired
- Arthelper.Ai - Smart tools to promo and showcase your art.
- LensRentals.com - WILD15 for 15% off
Court (00:00)
Hey friends, welcome back to The Wild Photographer. Thanks for joining and listening in today. I'm gonna start off by admitting that the title of this episode sounds very clickbaity, and I'm sorry for that, but that is not the intention. The intention is to give you insight into pieces of camera gear that you're gonna come across that you might have, you might have questions about that are controversial.
you might be in photo classes or courses or watching YouTube videos or on a specialized photo trip and one guide says one thing and another guide says the other. There are really no right and wrongs here. That's one of the big takeaways, is that these are matters of opinion. So the intention of this episode is to distill these opinions down into bite-sized nuggets for the sake of this podcast, give you what the topic is, why it's controversial.
Why people love them, why people hate them, and then also my personal take.
Now, when I say controversial, I'm obviously not talking about controversial in the grand scheme of things. Nobody's gonna lose over nobody is losing sleep over whether you own or use a tripod. At least I hope they're not. But within photography, especially if you spend any amount of time reading photography forums or watching videos on YouTube, talking with other photographers, you will find that there are certain pieces of gear that people have surprisingly strong opinions about, like really strong opinions.
And they will really battle for those. They're gonna convince you. There are photographers who believe you should always use a tripod. There are photographers who almost never use one. There are wildlife photographers who would happily carry a gigantic 600 millimeter F4 lens halfway around the planet. And there are others who look at that same lens and basically say, Why in the world would I carry such a a small bazooka around when I could just bring a zoom lens that gives me even more flexibility?
We talk about crop sensors. We got teleconverters in the lineup, polarizers. And what's interesting about all these is that I don't think there is actually a completely correct answer. And that's what I really want this episode to be about. This isn't five pieces of gear that are overrated or underrated. It's not five pieces of gear that you should not buy or have to go out tomorrow and get the very best one. It's really five pieces of gear where two very talented
Maybe professional photographers can have completely opposing opinions and both can be right. And I think that's actually a really healthy way to think about photography gear in general. the longer I've photographed, and especially the longer I've guided photographers around the world, the less interested I am in absolutes. You know, the you must have this, you should never use that. This is the only lens you ever need. that stuff makes for equally good clickbait, but it
you know, doesn't always make for great photography advice because it's not a black and white world. Photographing polar bears in the Canadian Arctic is very different from photographing birds in Borneo, which is different from photographing landscapes in Patagonia and different from walking around a national park all day carrying everything on your back. There are pros and cons to all these different things.
So we're gonna go through five controversial pieces of photo gear and why people love them, why people hate them, and perhaps maybe most importantly, where I sit with each just to give you a little bit of insight into my own world. So let's go ahead and get into it and start off with tripods. All right, I'm deliberately starting with tripod because I think this is.
Probably one of the most heated debates that people have the strongest opinions about. I love tripods and I also don't really like using tripods. Both of these things are true. There is a very respected school of landscape photography that basically says if you can use a tripod, you should use a tripod. And I totally get that. A tripod gives you a rock solid camera. It removes your own hand movement from the equation. It lets you shoot at ISO 100. It lets you shoot at F8 or F11, no matter what the light is.
And your shutter speed can drop down to one tenth of a second, one second, ten seconds, whatever you need. For landscape photography, this is extraordinary. Astrophotography, you absolutely need a tripod. Northern lights, same thing. Tripod is an instrumental piece of gear. You want to get that moving water effect with the slow shutter? Also, absolutely. Blue Hour, very useful. Really, any sort of long exposure, yeah. we're done debating. Bring a tripod for all those. But here's the other side.
Tripods are clunky, and I don't mean that disrespectfully to the tripod industry. I I still do love tripods. I have several of my own that I think are fantastic, but I mean physically they're very clunky. They they have three legs, they take up space, you have to extend them, you have to collapse them, you have to move the ball head or the pistol grip head, you have to level things, pick them up, move them 10 feet, raise, lower, sit them down again. It takes a lot of time, energy, and effort when things are.
Really rapidly evolving around you in the landscape. And meanwhile, the person standing next to you without a tripod already has tried six compositions in the same time it takes you to extend one leg of your tripod. That's the part that gets me. For me, photography is very much about experimenting with composition. I want to move left, I want to move right, I want to crouch down, I want to get higher, I want to try different angles. I want to walk 20 feet forward and realize I don't like that, and then walk 30 feet backwards. And with a tripod,
This introduces just enough friction that sometimes I give up or I stop experimenting, or maybe more importantly, I just don't try as many things. That's the controversy. A tripod unquestionably improves your stability, but can it actually decrease creativity? And I think sometimes yes. Especially today when image stabilization has gotten so darn good. We have stabilization in lenses, we have stabilization in camera bodies, we also have excellent high ISO performance.
There are photos I would have considered tripod only photos 15 years ago that I can very comfortably handhold today. You may have listened to my podcast with guest Will Patino who does his landscape photography handheld at one-fifth of a second and gets magazine quality results, like a legit, very well published photographer.
So I think the question has changed a little bit. Instead of asking, will a tripod improve the technical quality of this photograph, the answer to that might frequently be yes. I think the better question is, will using the tripod help me make a better photograph? And those are not always the same thing. if I'm standing in front of some extraordinary landscape at golden hour, for instance, and I know this is the scene.
I've found my composition. I've got a foreground, a mid-ground, a background, the light is gorgeous. Yes, I'm putting that camera on a tripod because it's one shot and I've found it. I'm going to ISO 100, F11, whatever shutter speed I need to get that right exposure, maybe a two-second timer to minimize camera movement, and boom. Let's just squeeze out every ounce of quality of this photo.
but if I'm walking through a landscape actively looking for compositions, I'm probably handheld. Like if I don't know what I'm gonna do and I'm still sort of sussing that out, I'm handheld. And wildlife, honestly, other than some very specialized situations, I'm handheld almost all the time.
So here's a little statement that's slightly controversial for you to noodle on. When we talk about tripods and the weight and the size, you know, we're we're constantly thinking about getting smaller and lighter weight. The greatest way you can save weight and space from a tripod is to leave it behind. But remember, on the flip side is that the fastest way to regret leaving it behind is watching the sky absolutely explode at sunset when you want ISO 100 F11, two-second exposure, and you just know this is gonna be the shot of the trip.
So my verdict is a tripod is absolutely indispensable when you need it. I just don't believe you need it nearly as often as some photographers say you do. I do bring one with me on nearly every trip. I might even have it in my backpack with me just because I'm okay carrying a little bit of extra weight and really stacking the deck in my favor. But I am handheld the vast majority of the time. So I am not in the camp of using a tripod anytime you possibly can use a tripod, which let's be honest, is the mantra of many a landscape photographer out there.
I want to take a quick break and thank MPB, one of the sponsors of the show. I think most photographers eventually accumulate a piece of gear that seemed absolutely essential when we bought it. And then six months later, we're looking at it sitting on the shelf, thinking, when was that last time I actually used this thing? And that's one of the reasons I really like MPB. They make it incredibly easy to take the gear you're no longer using and put that value towards something you'll actually use.
You can get a quote online and MPB arranges free insured shipping, they inspect the gear, and then you get paid without having to deal with listings, negotiating, responding to messages, or meeting someone in a parking lot with a thousand dollar lens. And it works just as well on the buying side too. Every camera and lens, as I said, is individually inspected.
Then it's tested and photographed for their website. So you can actually see the specific piece of equipment you're buying in photos, like not just a stock photo, but the actual lens or camera body, what have you. There's also a warranty and straightforward returns. so it just takes a lot of uncertainty out of buying used gear. So whether you're simplifying your kit, upgrading a lens, or turning some unused gear into your next photo trip fund, head on over to mpb.com and see what your gear is worth. All right, back to the show.
Controversial gear number two, giant super telephoto prime lenses. Okay, wildlife photographers, here we go. We're talking about the 400 millimeter 2.8s, the 600 millimeter F4, the the big guns out there. And let me just say right off the bat, they are spectacular. Let's let's just start there. Like no shade thrown. These lenses are incredible pieces of equipment. The sharpness that they exhibit, it's simply extraordinary. It's breathtaking. The autofocus is light speed fast. It's extraordinary as well.
The subject isolation, wonderful. And the big aperture is such a massive superpower when you're photographing in early morning, late evening, in forest canopies, cloudy conditions, all those places where wildlife photography gets really interesting and really aesthetic, but also really difficult. If you've ever photographed through a great 400, 2.8 or 600 millimeter F4 at dawn, you probably understand very much why this lens exists. It's beautiful.
But they're also huge. They're heavy and they are wildly expensive. They're challenging to travel with, and they basically need their own case. they're also a fixed focal length, which can be a challenge for photographers. And that last one is where things get kind of more controversial and interesting because
With wildlife photography, this is what these lenses are really built for. Well, of course, they're also for sports photography, but that's not really what we're talking about here. But they are wildlife first lenses.
and the thing is is that animals don't care about the photo that they're about to be in. You can have the perfect portrait of a lion at 75 yards away, and then that lion walks right toward you and it actually gets within 30, 20 yards. Who who knows?
And congratulations, you now have a stunning photograph of its left nostril. This is why, you know, I am I'm such a fan of really high-quality telephoto zooms, like the 100 to 500 class, the 200 to 600 class, the venerable age-old 100 to 400 class, all these variations. There are many, many out there. and the thing I'll say right off the bat is: no, they generally do not give you F4 at 600 millimeters.
But what they give you is versatility. And versatility in wildlife photography is so extremely important. I've said this in different forms over the years, but I I think your keeper rate is sometimes more important than theoretical image quality. Like the sharpest lens in the world isn't useful if the composition is wrong because the animal suddenly moved 20 feet closer.
So what's better than having a $15,000 Super Telephoto Prime? Well, frankly, the zoom lens that was actually able to get the shot, you could zoom out and get the whole landscape. You could then zoom in a half a second later to get a full face composition.
Now, before everyone with a 400 2.8 comes after me, there is obviously another side.
let's say it's 6 o'clock in the morning. You're photographing in very low light. You have a 500 millimeter zoom that's an F7.1 at the long end. Your friend next to you is shooting with a 600 F4. you might be at ISO 12,800, which is pretty high. Meanwhile, they're at ISO 4000. That is a significant difference.
yes, today's denoise technology is extraordinary, but I would much rather start with a cleaner file than rescue one later. So this really comes down to the type of wildlife photography that you do. If you're sitting in a hide photographing birds in a predictable location, a big prime, it's it's amazing and it's not all that inconvenient. If you're photographing wildlife where you're moving around, the animals moving around, you're in safari vehicles bumping around, or you're
hiking, maybe you're flying across the world to go on a photo trip, or even on the trip itself, you're in small bush flights, you know, a small aircraft. That giant prime becomes just harder to deal with, It's not impossible to deal with, just harder. And I think the real controversy is that for years, the giant primes were almost the symbol that you have arrived as a wildlife photographer. It might be the thing that you're working towards. You're you're producing photographs, you're selling photographs.
with the hope that one day you can afford one of these. I I know that I was there for a long, long time. And then you see someone carrying that huge white or black lens and it's it's like, okay, this person is serious. They know what they're doing. but today's telephoto zooms are so darn good that I just don't think that's totally true anymore. And I I'll tell you a story. I was on a a photo trip that I was guiding and I was with probably one of the most professional photographers I've ever been with.
But it's not because of the lens he was using, it's because of his backstory. He was a portrait photographer for one of the Beatles. He shot for the BBC over many years. And he was shooting with a great camera body, but with a Tamron 150 to 600 millimeter lens. Like that's not a super expensive lens. That's not a primo lens. It's definitely not a big prime telephoto. Yet the photos he was getting were extraordinary. And I I asked him about it. I just was straightforward. I'm like, I'm surprised. I mean, you you clearly are pro.
You could have purchased or rented anything you wanted. Why did you choose this? And he said, Honestly, I'd rather have the flexibility. the sharpness is so good nowadays because we've just been advancing so much throughout the years that the sharpness on this $1,200 Tamron is everything he needed. He's gonna do some post-processing, he's gonna do a little bit of sharpening, he's gonna do some masking. And he's like, I'd rather have the 600.
be able to get the megapixels. I'd rather be able to zoom out and go wider to 150 to get an environmental portrait. And yes, I could have brought the 600 Prime, but it wouldn't have given me what I wanted.
So it's a really important point to think about. You can absolutely make world-class photography without a 600 F4. Would I personally enjoy owning one? I highly covet the 400 2.8. absolutely. I would love to have one. Would I enjoy carrying it through the Atlanta airport on my way to Botswana? Quite a bit less.
Every time I'm out in Africa or in Asia, really anywhere where big wildlife is found, I'm so grateful when I can zoom from 100 to 400 or 100 to 500 and get everything in between. Are there times throughout that trip that I am disgusted with F7.1? Gosh, that that's a that's a strong word.
Are there times that I'm less satisfied with my F7.1 at 500 millimeters? Absolutely. Do I think I'm gonna rent a 400 two point eight the next time I go on a trip? Yeah, it really goes through my mind. Have I done so yet? Nope, because the pros outweigh the cons for me on these Zoom telephotos.
Now, that being said, I do stack the deck in my favor and I get a quote unquote pro version of those Zoom telephotos. That's just my own personal preference. But I find that because cameras overall, cameras and lenses overall, have gotten so much sharper and so much better, the autofocus is fast, And there are ways I can blur out the background now in post-processing. So
The the pros of these super telephoto primes, they're getting a little bit less and less. So just be aware of that. There's still a pro choice. You're still going to watch football games, and all the photographers on the sidelines will have these lenses. And there's there is justification. So I'm not taking them out of the equation, but just another example of where it's kind of split. It's controversial. There are pros and cons on both sides of the aisle here.
okay, controversial gear piece number three, crop sensors for wildlife. I know this one gets pretty technical pretty quickly, but I think it's a very important debate. This is about crop sensor cameras. Are they secretly better for wildlife photography because you get that quote unquote extra reach? Remember, crop frame sensors are in a way kind of the more introductory cameras. They're usually sub-1,500.
And depending on the camera brand you use, they give you between a 1.4 and a 1.6 multiplier effect on your focal length. So when we're talking about like a 400 millimeter, you have to multiply that, or you get to multiply that by 1.4, 1.5, 1.6 to get your actual focal length that's happening. So they can be wildly powerful. So the question is: yeah, are they better for wildlife because you can get more reach, or is that
Extra reach mostly kind of like a misunderstanding, and you sacrifice too much quality because on the flip side, crop sensor cameras don't have quite the same megapixels, they don't have quite the same low light sensitivity So let's clear up one thing right away. Putting a 400 millimeter lens on a crop sensor camera does not magically turn it into a longer lens, it's still a 400 millimeter lens.
What changes is the field of view. You're essentially seeing a narrower piece of the image circle compared with full frame sensor. So this idea that your 400 suddenly becomes a 640 millimeter lens on a 1.6 crop camera isn't literally what's happening optically.
And this is where your purest full-frame photographers will say, Well, I'm never even gonna touch that because I'm not gonna sacrifice image quality or megapixels or anything that might reduce the quality of my image because I'm already at a flagship top-end camera. But there's another part to this story, and this is pixel density. If your crop sensor camera is putting a whole bunch of megapixels onto that smaller sensor area, you might end up with substantially more pixels on the bird.
Than you would if you photographed the same bird from the same distance with the same lens, but using full frame cameras and then cropping afterwards. And that's what actually matters: pixels on the subject. So I think the funny argument goes something like this: the crop sensor photographer says, Well, I'm kind of getting bonus reach. But then the full frame photographer says, No, you're just taking a pre-crop.
Photograph, like something that I could do on the computer afterwards. and then the crop photographer says, that's great. My pre-cropped photograph has 32 megapixels on the bird. And now we actually have a debate because if you're photographing small birds or distant wildlife, anywhere where you're almost always focal length limited, crop sensor bodies can actually be quite phenomenal. you get smaller, less expensive bodies in many cases.
And you may get more effective pixel density on the subject. You're filling the frame more with the animal. And that's all great. But, and it's a big but here, is nature and wildlife photography doesn't happen only in bright sunlight. we we all know this deeply. I photograph in some pretty darn dark places, rainforests, a lot of dawn and dusk, blue hour, places and times of year with heavy cloud cover. And this is where I personally really value a full frame.
generally speaking, the larger sensor gives you better ISO capabilities, gives you better dynamic range, being able to see the lights in the dark and the dark in the lights, and just kind of overall flexibility in challenging lighting conditions. And that's a huge reason why I've personally gravitated to full frame over the many years. if I'm photographing, say, gorillas under a forest canopy and I'm already at F4.
One over 500 and my ISO is climbing, you know, just higher and higher and higher as the clouds come over and the animals go underneath the trees. I really need and want every advantage I can get from my camera body. But if I'm photographing birds at 10 in the morning in great light and I'm consistently cropping half the image anyway, crop sensors start sounding pretty darn attractive to me.
So I think saying full frame is better across the board is just as wrong as saying crop is better for wildlife because it gives you more reach. Like both are kind of right and both are kind of wrong. The real question is where are your limitations as you, the photographer? Where are your limitations? Are you usually limited by light in the style of photography and the places you travel to or maybe even your next photo trip? if you're limited by light, full frame is very compelling.
I would never choose a crop frame camera over a full frame for photographing, say, northern lights or astrophotography. Or on the other hand, are you usually limited by focal length and pixels on distant subjects? A high-resolution crop body can maybe be the solution here.
And frankly, if you carry two camera bodies with you out on trips and in the field, there is an interesting argument for having one of each to kind of have one dedicated for those moments when you're limited by light and the other for when you're limited by reach. It could be a really, really compelling one-two punch there that kind of satisfies both arguments, wouldn't you say?
Okay, moving on to number four, teleconverters. Teleconverters may be the ultimate photography compromise because the sales pitch sounds extraordinary. I'll be honest. You have a 400 millimeter lens, you put a little disc on the end of it, and it's a 1.4 teleconverter. and then all of a sudden you're at 560 millimeters. Wow, boom, you're all set, right? and then teleconverter itself is
Quite tiny compared to buying another lens. So it gives you that added flexibility without having to carry and/or buy another lens. They're also relatively inexpensive compared to a big new 560 millimeter lens. And that's amazing, right? except, of course, optical physics at the end of the day kind of keeps the score here.
A 1.4 times teleconverter costs you one full stop of light, and then a two times costs you two stops of light. So your beautiful fast lens like a 400, 2.8 or a 600 F4, is now quite a bit slower. You can also potentially lose some image quality. these things are getting better and better all the time, and I've heard from a lot of folks that use these that the 1.4s are almost unnoticeable, but then they jump to a two times and they say, yeah, it's very noticeable.
So it kind of makes me scratch my head that, you know, a 1.4 times can be nothing and a two times is everything as far as the difference goes. so you know, I don't know. I I still hold my reservations. I'll get to my opinions in a second. But the other key thing is that with these, not only do you lose light, but auto focus performance can change as well. everything becomes just slightly more demanding when you're using a teleconverter.
And this is where people start asking the really interesting question of whether a teleconverter is actually better than just cropping your photo afterwards. And I I think this is a very, very worthy debate because essentially you're asking whether you would rather enlarge the image optically before it reaches a sensor or capture the original image, give yourself all the leeway to crop in or stay as is, and then just crop the pixels afterwards.
And the answer is unfortunately for anyone looking for like a really simple takeaway here is it depends. you know, we're kind of seeing a theme in this podcast, which is why these things are controversial in the first place. A lot of these things are very photographer dependent. So here it depends on the lens, it depends on the teleconverter, depends on your camera, depends on how many megapixels your camera body has, and and the light in this situation, the light in the scenario, the environment, the landscape, the
the light on the wildlife or lack thereof. It also depends on how much crop tolerance you have. Like how much can you crop in on your photo and retain the quality, whether it's just for your own personal satisfaction, whether it's for an actual use case, like you might be trying to submit to a photo contest or put your photo on a website or social media versus like magazine quality. So I personally think the 1.4 teleconverters can be really, really useful and fantastic.
particularly on high quality lenses designed or like truly designed to work with them. Like that's something I didn't cover in the big prime section, but you do get that added benefit that teleconverters work really well for big primes.
And if I'm heading somewhere maybe new or where I just know there's a decent chance I'm gonna need some more reach, There's a very compelling argument for this 1.4 teleconverter. But the two times teleconverter, even though they're both teleconverters, it in my mind it's where I'm more cautious. Like I don't view these things as equal. I don't say yes teleconverters, no teleconverters. I really look at it between 1.4 and the two times.
and this is another place that I personally draw the line is that I will not hesitate recommending a 1.4 teleconverter for a big prime, but I'm very hesitant to recommend it for zoom telephotos.
The only exception I might make is with the venerable 70 to 200 millimeter class. And the reason is that most Zoom telephotos don't start off with a good enough aperture and high enough image quality that you can take that ding on both. same thing with focusing speed, like autofocusing speed. The big primes, yes, but your 100 to 400s, 200 to 500s, not really.
The one exception I'll make is that 7200s, because they are already so good as far as the optical quality. They're very often F2.8. They're usually extremely fast with autofocusing speed. This is where I could see using a 1.4 times extender and doing just fine with it. The problem is that do the math, 1.4 on a 70 to 200 doesn't really increase your reach very much, does it? Like it's not giving you a huge advantage and
The the lower focal lengths, they basically, make me really scratch my head as to whether I should just be cropping the photo afterwards. I know a lot of folks that will either ask me about or will bring a seventy to two hundred and then bring it two times instead of bringing a bigger zoom telephoto lens. And that's great. That would make a 70 to 200 a 140 to 400. And if you're at F two point eight aperture on the seventy-two hundred, that's
You know, 140, 400, F5.6, which is pretty decent, right? I think you're just gonna have to make your own decision on that. Like I think that the image quality takes a hit. I think that I'd much rather shoot something at F two point eight or f4, get that better low light capability, get the better background blur versus sacrificing. I'd rather bring a dedicated lens that I can just have on a second camera body, but this is where you know your own personal style is paramount.
So again, a two times teleconverter is where I become more cautious. we are losing two stops of light, and that's quite a bit. You know, that's like shooting at ISO 1600 and then needing to go to ISO 6400. Like that's a pretty big deal. if you start with an F4 lens, you're at F eight.
If you're already using something like an F5.6, now you're at F11 if the exposure stays the same. And if we're photographing wildlife early in the morning, suddenly your ISO is really, really blasting upwards, and you have to start asking whether that extra focal length was worth everything you gave up to get that focal length. Of course, if you're photographing in Fantastic Light, that situation changes quite a bit.
So here's my my quick takeaway on teleconverters. A teleconverter is the cheapest way to make your lens longer and darker at the same time, which sounds a little bit like a backhanded compliment. And I I guess it kind of is. but the gist is making your lens longer for a few hundred dollars and a few ounces more instead of spending many thousands of dollars on another lens is kind of miraculous. Like let's be honest. And the quality for what you're you're spending and what you're doing is pretty darn good.
I just think you need to view it as a specialized tool rather than like free up for grabs focal length increase. there is no free focal length. There is a cost to it. And physics is very good at keeping track on this. And you it's really hard to have your cake and eat it too with teleconverters. So again, you're gonna see people, hear people out there that use them, love them, but it's very, very circumstantial.
Before we continue, I want to take a minute to thank ArtHelper.com for supporting the show. I've been using ArtHelper for quite some time now, and it's a phenomenal tool for photographers to automate a lot of their kind of non creative part of the process. Things like keywording,
wall mock-ups, and even titling your photos, these things can get pretty tedious. And I honestly just love outsourcing this stuff. And if you are the kind of person that wants to promote your work even more, the same program, arthelper.com, can come up with things like blog themes, email templates, and a heck of a lot more. But what's really exciting in their world right now is their push into creating communities around art.
On their new community platform, you can discover other photographers and other artists. You can share your own work, you can get critiques on your work, follow discussions, and even become part of a global directory where people looking for real human created artwork can find you. Best of all, it's free to join. So if you're a photographer
and you'd like to try to take your photography to the next level, go check out arthelper.com. Big thanks, ArtHelper, and let's get back to the show.
Gear piece number five, the circular polarizer. Dun dun dun.
Alright, this is for my landscape photographers out there. Circular polarizers. I love them. I also think that they're one of the most overused pieces of gear in landscape photography. and again, true to the nature of this episode, both can be true at the same time.
A key thing is that a circular polarizer can do something that is, you know, honestly, difficult, if not impossible, to recreate in Lightroom afterwards. The idea of cutting glare and reflection is a physics thing and it has to be done, mostly has to be done in camera in the moment. And that's absolutely huge.
If you're photographing, let's say, landscapes after a rainstorm and there's a lot of wet foliage out there, a polarizer can remove that little bit of sheen on the reflected light from the leaves, and suddenly those greens become much richer. If you photograph let's say a mountain stream and you can cut the reflection off the surface of the water and see the rocks underneath, that's fantastic.
You can increase the saturation of certain colors naturally because you're eliminating reflected light. It's truly an amazing tool. But then along the way, we discovered that polarizers can also make blue skies darker. And we kind of went a little bit astray. And if if you have shot with a polarizer and toyed around with them on bluebird days, blue sky days, you probably know what I'm talking about. You rotate the polarizer, the sky gets a little darker, and you say, ooh, that's nice. And you keep on rotating.
It gets darker and darker, and you say, ooh, that's even better because we're kind of judging this from the viewfinder or the back of the L C D screen. And that can sometimes be a little bit dangerous. You keep on going with rotating until suddenly you're taking landscape photographs where the sky looks like almost like an otherworldly upper atmosphere of a planet. Like it's a artificial color. It's not something we would normally see with our eyes. and then with ultra-wide angle lenses, you get.
Kind of uneven polarizations across the sky where one section is extremely dark blue and another is much lighter. it's one of those effects where just because you can see that the filter is doing something doesn't necessarily mean you should turn it up all the way. And this happens in editing too. the clarity slider, dehaze slider, saturation,
If a little bit is good, more must be better, right? Well, not necessarily. So I think the best use of a polarizer
isn't necessarily skies, it's really those reflections. That's where I think it really earns a space in the camera bag. Water, wet vegetation, glare off of rocks or leaves, maybe photographing through certain reflective surfaces. Those are the things where it gives me an image that I simply could not have gotten otherwise.
And there is another downside too. Polarizers do cut light. They limit the amount of light getting into your sensor. So if I'm already photographing in dim conditions, let's say under a rainforest canopy, I'm probably gonna take it off. I don't want to sacrifice that light unless the effect I'm getting is genuinely worth it. So the controversy really isn't whether polarizers work. They they absolutely work.
The controversy for me is whether they should live on your lens permanently. And for me, that's it's a hard no. It is a tool. It is a specialty tool. use it when you see the problem that it's designed to solve. I would recommend that you don't use polarizers just because you've seen a photographer use one online or because you've gotten a couple nice shots over the years and you think, well, if a couple nice shots turned out better because of the polarizer.
Having it on all the time must make it even better for all my shots. it's just simply not the case. Remember, think reflections. You can also think blue skies, you can think clouds, but remember you have a real strong chance of degrading your overall image quality, getting some weird effects where the fringes or the corners might have a little bit of difference from what the middle of the shot looks like. and if you're photographing in dim conditions, is it worth having a higher ISO?
To give you a little bit more richness in the blues that you might have already been able to saturate and post anyway.
So I want to give you a bonus one here. And I have to mention it because I've already done an entire episode on this. and it might be one of the most surprising polarizing pieces of gear in all of photography. And yeah, polarizing filters. Yeah, sorry, I had to. but I'm not gonna completely rehash that episode. You can go back and listen to it if you want the whole deep dive, but we're talking about UV filters here, and here's like the 30 second version.
In modern digital photography, I'm not really using a UV filter because I need to filter UV light. I'm using it because I want more or less a sacrificial piece of glass in front of my very expensive piece of glass. I'm often photographing in dust, I'm photographing in rain, I'm photographing around salt water,
I'm photographing from Safari vehicles where there are metal railings that I might bump my camera on.
and I really like the fact that when something needs to be cleaned or let's say the lens gets scratched, I'm dealing with a replaceable filter rather than the front element of the actual multi-thousand dollar lens.
So, right off the bat, that's that's the pro side. they are protective, they protect resale value. In many cases, they're easier to clean. It just keeps your actual lens front a lot cleaner. but the argument against UV filters is pretty reasonable as well. why would you buy a super expensive lens containing incredibly sophisticated optical glass and then put another comparatively
inexpensive piece of glass in front of it.
I get it. and also sometimes these UV filters are not inexpensive. If you have a really big front lens element, like a 92 millimeter or heck even an 82 millimeter, and you want to get a really great UV filter, they could be in the hundreds of dollars. But I will say this, on most of my lenses,
I do use a UV filter 100% of the time. the key thing for me is that if you're going to use one, buy a good one. Don't spend thousands of dollars on a lens and then put the cheapest UV filter you can find in front of it. And when I say cheap, I'm talking about like the $20, $30, $40 range. This is really a case where you get what you pay for and I'm aiming for something around $100. Polar Pro makes a great one. Hoya.
B and W and then Singray is kind of the elite $400 range. I think that might be a little bit overkill, but nevertheless, $100, $140, Get something with a multi-coated surface. It's easier to clean, it repels dust, and it's just gonna work a lot better for you. So I get the argument against them. I prioritize because of the style of photography. I am traveling a lot, I'm in.
Precarious situations a lot. I want to protect A, the resale value of my lens. I want to B make it easier to clean.
And C, if the worst happens and I drop my lens or bang it on the railing, if I scratch it, if I, who heaven forbid, break my lens, like break the glass on the front of it, a UV filter is gonna take the absolute brunt of that. And then I'm only at out $100 if it actually does break versus a couple thousand dollars for having to get a new lens.
Okay, so there you have it. Five pieces of gear photographers apparently cannot agree on, plus a bonus controversy that we've already kind of beaten up in another episode. We got tripods, giant super telephoto primes, crop sensor cameras, teleconverters, circular polarizers, and the good old UV filter. And I think the interesting thing is that I didn't actually tell you any of these are bad. That's the takeaway. The the longer and the more I photograph, the more I think gear advice has to come with some context. It's subjective.
I think we sometimes want photography to be simpler than it is. We want someone to tell us the best wildlife lens, the best camera, the best tripod, whether we should buy the teleconverter or steer clear of them. But nature photography is this giant spectrum of conditions. not just conditions on the ground, but conditions for the photographer. What are they seeing? What are they going through?
A photographer might be sitting in a wildlife blind doing something completely different from someone hiking eight miles through Rocky Mountain National Park to get that epic landscape shot. Those are very, very different scenarios. A photographer in a vehicle on the Serengeti has very different needs than someone photographing gorillas under the canopy in Rwanda.
Someone photographing the blue hour has very different needs than someone focusing on high contrast black and white photography during the day.
So I like to think of it in a bit of a different way. Instead of asking whether a piece of gear is good or bad, I think there's a different question to ask here. And the question is what problem does this piece of gear solve? That's it. If your tripod solved the problem of needing a five second exposure, it's an amazing piece of gear. If the tripod is preventing you from moving around and finding the best composition, it might be hurting you.
If your giant prime lens solves the problem of photographing distant wildlife at dawn, it's phenomenal. if it means you can't zoom out when wildlife approaches or you're really into environmental portraits where there's wildlife in landscape, that's a real compromise. If your crop sensor is putting more pixels on a distant bird, that's great. But if you're constantly struggling in low light with
Higher ISOs than you want, maybe a full frame is a better way to go.
Ultimately, the more time you spend actually photographing in the field, the less absolute your opinions about gear become. Because you realize all this stuff, they're just tools, frankly. And the best piece of gear is really the one that helps you make the photograph you're trying to make in the first place, where you're standing, under the conditions you actually have, what your own creative vision is.
So I'd love to hear from you on this one because I guarantee you there are some strong opinions out there. You might have been shaking your head at certain parts of this. And I I would love to hear what your thoughts are. What's a piece of photography gear that you think is completely overrated, or a piece of gear that you love that everyone else seems to hate? Head on over to my YouTube channel and leave me a comment.
I do see all those comments and I really enjoy hearing from you and having conversations.
Frankly, some of the things that you might ask or talk about might be fodder for a part two of this episode. Who knows? Maybe we're talking about monopods. Maybe I switch over to things like lens hoods or camera straps. And yeah, we'll keep on going from there.
But for now, we'll leave those other controversies for another day. So thanks so much for tuning in, folks. Get out there, experiment with your gear, question some of the conventional wisdom, and most importantly, keep having fun making your own photographs. Talk to you next time.